I disagree on the talent thing--heck, even on the holding a note thing, since her pitch is always flat--but maying holding "a" note doesn't necessarily mean holding the "right" note. She's got controlled yelling down to a viable occupation, I'll give her that. I can't listen to her sing without my own vocal cords aching in protest, though.


And Ashlee isn't bad for lip-syncing...It's her on the recording, after all, so she clearly sings at some point...it's really just bad that she missed the cues to her own song. She should know that stuff.