Posted by Anne Onymous on Fri, 08/22/2003 - 11:00am.
Archived comment by marinerd:
I see we're flying off in all directions here, like we tend to do. That's cool, but I was trying to stay specifically on the one instance of the Black Sox Scandal, and whether or not the players who cheated deserved the punishment they received. I thought it was a no-brainer that they did, and was shocked to find ParU disagreed.
Getting into hard choices, such as X or Y, is tangential to my point. I agree that in such a situation conscience and flexibility are very important. But it doesn't change my mind about the original argument.
I see we're flying off in all directions here, like we tend to do. That's cool, but I was trying to stay specifically on the one instance of the Black Sox Scandal, and whether or not the players who cheated deserved the punishment they received. I thought it was a no-brainer that they did, and was shocked to find ParU disagreed.
Getting into hard choices, such as X or Y, is tangential to my point. I agree that in such a situation conscience and flexibility are very important. But it doesn't change my mind about the original argument.